Skip to main content

A Rant On the Paranormal Fiction Genre

So last week I did Katie Phillips amazing Author Brand Challenge! It was totally incredible and in just five days I learned so much about myself as a writer and my writing than I have in a long time. When she asked us (the participants) what some of our takeaways and breakthroughs were, I said being a part of the challenge has made me take my writing and myself as a writer/author more seriously. It was sort of empowering in a way. Like now that my genre, my audience, my voice is clearer and more specific I feel so much more confident in myself. I'll do a post on this probably next week because seriously the things I learned about myself and my writing sort of blew my mind all week, but for this post I want to talk about a particular breakthrough I had.

Alright, before I start on my rant about the paranormal genre let me clear something up. Paranormal is usually associated with ghosts and that sort of thing. I'm not a fan of ghosts stories and that's why I was hesitant to say I write in that genre. But when I did research and looked up the actual meaning and books associated with the genre, paranormal actually involves shape-shifters, vampires, werewolves and all that. Yeah ghosts are lumped in there too but they're a pretty small portion of the genre. Supernatural, however, (and when I read this it made so much sense to me. I was like how did I not realize this before??) is all about the angels and demons and all that. So like Cassandra Clare's books would be considered supernatural. Though she also has vampires and stuff in there too so I guess her book is sort of a genre hybrid.

Day three was about finding our niche. Katie is so specific and really encouraged us to ponder and think about what genres we're drawn to. In her live video she even said, if you could only write one genre for the rest of your life what would it be? That really got me thinking. I totally agreed with her about how to narrow down our audience and reach the readers who are interested in our work, we have to be specific and consistent about what genre we write. The more I thought about it the more I realized a lot of the authors I love do just this. A.G. Howard writes exclusively YA retellings and NA historical fantasy. Nadine Brandes writes historical fantasy and Holly Black focuses on paranormal fiction (most of which have to do with the Fae). And after doing a ton of research and thinking and processing I came to a conclusion that I knew in my heart was right. I think I've known it for a long time but was always nervous about being so open and honest about the kind of genre I enjoy. Because I'm a Christian and Christians aren't supposed to read paranormal fiction. Or enjoy it. Or watch it. Or have anything to do with it. Fantasy? Sure! Go right ahead. Write all the fantasy you want. Sci-fi? Uh yes! That's safe. 

But paranormal? With the... vampires and werewolves and things that go bump in the night? Ummm yeah no. You can't write that. Even though paranormal fiction is a sub-genre of fantasy. But Katie's questions were very specific and made me realize that over the past two years or so I've really grown to know for sure that the paranormal genre is my passion. I enjoy writing in that genre like no other. Yes I love myself a good scifi story and I do love retellings and fantasy. I've written in all of those genres. But the one that makes me smile and excited? The characters I feel truly connected with and the stories that pour out of my heart? Those have shape-shifters and worlds within our world and banshees and djinn and Shades. 

What makes shape-shifters and werewolves and vampires any different from the creatures in fantasy books anyways? The elves and orcs and giants and ogres and fairies? Nothing other than the fact that the former is associated with a genre who's writers do a disservice to it by adding in tons of sex and darkness and violence and gore and the latter is associated with great creations like The Lord of the Rings and The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. 

People only see the gore and the darkness and the explicit content in the paranormal genre. I'll be the first to admit it is hard! to find good books in that genre. When I was doing research to make sure this is the correct genre, I couldn't really find any decent books that I would willingly read. Because I don't like tons of sex and gore and violence in my books. But I do love the genre. And I love the broken and needy characters that that genre produces. The hopeful stories and redemption arcs and stories of good and evil and forgiveness and true love that comes from that genre. I love those! It's why I love shows like The Vampire Diaries and Teen Wolf. Because yes, I love the paranormal elements to them but I love the characters and the world and the themes and stories that come out of them. 

And that's where the genre gap comes in. The workbook we used also asked what gaps are in our genre that we can fill? This one took me a while but after a few days of thinking and even after just getting to this point in the blog post I realized there was a huge gap in the paranormal genre! A gap for clean, good books, that yes, still have romance (because I love a good romance, who doesn't??) but that doesn't have explicit content in it. There's a gap for books in the paranormal genre that can really show off the themes I talked about above. That can give people hope and show them what forgiveness, love (romantic and familial) and redemption looks like. Another thing we talked about: message. I'm still working on this one but I do know this: I always want my books to make someone smile and give them hope. And I feel I can best do that through this genre. 

I'm realizing as I do more research and brainstorm ways to reach my ideal reader that this is going to be hard because as far as I know, there aren't a lot of Christians actively reading in this genre or looking for good books in this genre. Which means I did do one thing right! I narrowed my audience down just like Katie wanted us to. Waaay down. I have a very clear idea of what kind of reader I want to reach. But now it's just finding a way to reach them. I will, I'm determined to find them, but I know it's going to take some time and a lot of brainstorming as to how best to reach them. 

So, yeah, those are my thoughts on this matter. If you can't tell, I'm pretty passionate about this. I really hope this post reaches someone in my same place I am. I hope this post tells you that you can write in this genre and still bring light and good to people. Yes, I have to check myself and watch myself and pray a lot and think over things way more than I'm sure writers in other genres would. This genre can bring darkness and can lead you astray if you're not careful and don't have the strength to pull back and set clear boundaries for yourself. I make a habit of not having any witches or wiccan type magic in my books. There are no ghosts. No explicit content, no swearing and as of right now in the paranormal WIP I'm working on right now, there aren't even any vampires or werewolves. So, yes, be careful and prayerful and search your heart but if done correctly this genre can reach so many people and I hope with my works I can touch people's hearts and inspire and encourage them the same way other works in this genre have for me. 

What do you guys think of this topic? Yay or nay to the paranormal genre? 


  1. I feel like the paranormal genre gets a really bad rap. Yeah, there’s a lot of junk in there (I don’t think I’ve read anything that WASN'T junk thus far), but I think that there’s still some really good works in there - it’s just been hidden. And I definitely agree with a lot of your points - it can bring us down a really dark path. But we can still use it for good!

    Great post, Melody!

    1. I definitely agree! It's really hard to find a good book in that genre but when you do find a gem it's worth the wait! :) Thanks! :)

  2. I'm sure there can be some good paranormal out there, but I have as yet to see it ;p Also, I don't like vampires or werewolves at all. I think of them as very dark creatures, no matter how they are portrayed. But interesting post!

    1. I agree. It is hard to find a clean paranormal book out there. But that's why I want to write in this genre. To bring more light to it instead of contributing to the darkness. I used to write vampire books but not so much anymore. Now when I do write in the paranormal genre I lean more toward other supernatural creatures because I didn't feel very comfortable writing about all the darkness that goes along with vampire stories. Thanks for reading and commenting! I love hearing your point of view! :)


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Happy New Years!!

Happy New Years everyone! 2019 is officially here! Some parts of last year felt like they went by so slowly while other parts feel like they were a blur. But overall, 2018 was a good year and I have a feeling 2019 will be a good year too. 2019 is a new season of life for me and others and I'm so excited to see what God has planned for myself, friends and family.

I know I've already posted my goals for 2019 but there are a few more I want to add. Since writing the Looking Forward to 2019 post, I had a few epiphanies that I think are important.

First of all, one of the authors I follow on Instagram wrote a post today about the difference between dreams and goals. Goals are achievable. They can be accomplished. Dreams can be too, but sometimes certain dreams are out of our control and when we fail to accomplish that dream, we fail. She said how she really wanted to sell a book in 2019. To pitch a book to her agent and get it out there. But that's not a goal. That's a drea…

January 2019 Wrap-Up

Wow! The first month of the year is nearly over! I can't believe it's almost already February. Just one more month and it'll be my birthday!

With the end of January, I'm really starting to think about what I want to do this year, mostly concerning this blog and my writing and stuff. I want to change some things blogger-wise and grow my audience, though I'm still trying to brainstorm and figure out the best ways to do that. There are just a lot of thoughts and ideas floating around in my head right now that are hard to organize and put down on paper (or type out on keyboard), but I'm sure with all these ideas and thoughts, there will come lots more blog posts. So instead of trying to organize my messy thoughts right now, I think I'll just do my wrap-up same as usual.

January Writing: This month's writing has been good. December was a hard month for me. I was super burnt out and blocked in everything I did. Writing three different versions of my Peter Pan …

Friday in Review: Fictional Vacation/Would you Rather

Happy Friday! So, they awesome Lily Cat tagged me in this fictional vacation/would you rather challenge and I am so excited to do this. It sounds so fun!

Alright so here's the deal:

~ Include the graphic Madeline made.
~ Answer the Questions 
~ Tag some other people if you feel so inclined
Let's jump right into this! 
Would you rather... 
Train with demigods for the summer at Camp Halfblood OR attend Hogwarts to learn some spells for a semester?
How is this even a question? ;) Camp Halfblood of course! I adore the Percy Jackson series, so I would do just about anything to be a halfblood for the Summer. The real question is, who would my parent be?? My enneagram four side who loves being special and different wants me to be a kid of one of the big three... maybe Hades just to make myself extra special and unique from everyone else ;) But most likely I'd end up being like a Posiedon kid... or if we're being real probably Apollo cuz I'm a writer and all that, even though …